MyHustle · Blog · News

Get the weekly digest

New posts and market headlines every Friday. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

Price from sold listings, set a floor, and mark down on a schedule

4 min read

Most listings that never sell aren't bad items. They're priced from the wrong number. Copy the active listings and you join a crowd of sellers who are also waiting. Guess low and you give away money you never knew you had.

This post covers a simple way to set a starting price and a floor, and how to bring the price down on a schedule so an item doesn't sit forever.

Read sold listings first

Active listings show you competition. Sold listings show you demand. When you price, start with what the same item actually sold for recently, in the same condition.

Write down three numbers from the sold results:

Your starting price usually belongs between the typical and the high sale. Your floor sits closer to the low.

Check how fast it sells

Price matters less when an item is in demand, and more when it isn't. A quick way to judge demand is to compare how many sold to how many are listed right now.

If 30 sold in the last 90 days and 10 are listed now, buyers are taking them as fast as sellers list them, so you can start near the top. If 5 sold and 60 are listed, buyers have plenty of choices, so expect to price closer to typical and wait longer.

If there are almost no sales at all, the item may be rare, or it may just not sell. Price it as a test, and be ready to adjust after a couple of weeks.

Know your floor before a buyer asks

Offers come in fast, and it's easy to accept one that loses money. Work out your floor before you list, then set your auto-decline at or above it.

Your floor is the lowest price that still covers your cost, the fees, and the minimum profit you want. Fees differ by platform. On Mercari, the selling fee is 10% of the item price plus any shipping the buyer pays. (Mercari fees)

Here's an example. You paid $12 for a pair of boots, supplies cost $1, and you want at least $15 profit. The buyer pays $8 for shipping, and the label costs you the same $8.

Fee at a $40 price: 10% × ($40 + $8) = $4.80

Profit at $40: $40 − $4.80 − $12 − $1 = $22.20

To find the floor, ask what price leaves exactly $15:

Price − 10% × (price + $8) − $13 = $15, so the price is $32

So you'd list at $40 and decline anything under $32. That leaves room to negotiate without losing your profit.

Lower the price on a schedule, not on a mood

An item that hasn't sold after a few weeks is telling you something. The fix is a planned markdown, not a random price cut when you're frustrated.

A simple ladder looks like this:

For the boots, that's $40, then $36, then $33. You never go below $32.

Fix the listing before you cut the price

Sometimes the price isn't the problem. Before each markdown, take a minute to check the listing itself.

A better first photo can do more than a $5 price cut.

Count shipping in your price

Buyers compare the total they'll pay, not just the item price. A $35 item with $10 shipping can lose to a $40 item that ships free.

If you offer free shipping, raise the item price to cover the label, then rerun your floor with the new numbers. On platforms that charge fees on shipping too, the fee usually stays about the same either way, so compare what you keep after the label is paid.

Keep a short record

For each sale, write down the list price, the price it sold for, and how many days it took. After a few dozen sales, you'll learn how much room to leave for offers and how fast your categories move.

That record turns pricing from a guess into a habit you can repeat.

The short version

Fees and offer tools differ by platform and change over time. Check your marketplace's current fee page before you set a floor.