MyHustle · Blog · News

Get the weekly digest

New posts and market headlines every Friday. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

Same $40 item, four marketplaces: what each one leaves you

4 min read

The same $40 sweater can leave you very different amounts depending on where it sells. The fee rate is only part of it. Some marketplaces charge on shipping, some charge a flat fee on cheap items, and some take payment processing on top.

This post runs one item through four marketplaces so you can see how the math changes. Then it looks at what fees don't tell you.

The setup

Our example is a $40 sweater. On the marketplaces where the buyer pays shipping separately, the buyer pays $8. To keep the comparison clean, we leave out sales tax and optional ads. Each section notes where those change the math.

eBay

For most categories, eBay charges a final value fee of 13.6% of the total amount of the sale, plus $0.40 per order over $10. The total includes the shipping the buyer pays and the sales tax. (eBay selling fees)

eBay fee: 13.6% × ($40 + $8) = $6.53, plus $0.40 = $6.93

Sales tax would add a little more, because eBay charges its percentage on the tax too. You also buy the shipping label, so what you keep depends on how close your label cost comes to the $8.

Mercari

Mercari charges sellers a 10% selling fee on the item price plus any shipping the buyer pays. The buyer pays a separate Buyer Protection fee at checkout, which doesn't come out of your earnings. (Mercari fees)

Mercari fee: 10% × ($40 + $8) = $4.80

Poshmark

Poshmark charges a flat $2.95 on sales under $15, and 20% on sales of $15 or more. Poshmark provides a prepaid shipping label for the sale. (Poshmark guide)

Poshmark fee: 20% × $40 = $8.00

That's the highest fee of the four, but you don't shop for a label or pay for one up front. Poshmark is also running a holiday promotion right now that cuts what buyers pay for standard shipping to $0.99. It says seller fees don't change.

Etsy

Etsy charges $0.20 to list an item, whether or not it sells, and a 6.5% transaction fee on the total order, including the shipping you charge. (Etsy fee basics)

Etsy fees: 6.5% × ($40 + $8) = $3.12, plus $0.20 = $3.32

Etsy also lists payment processing fees separately, and those aren't included here. Etsy is built for handmade, vintage, and craft supplies, so check its rules before you list a general resale item.

The same math on a $12 item

Cheap items change the picture. A flat fee that seems small on a $40 sale can eat a big share of a $12 one.

Take a $12 item where the buyer pays $5 shipping:

On low-priced items, it often makes sense to bundle several pieces into one sale or to use a platform with a percentage fee.

Live selling has its own fees

Live shopping platforms price differently. On Whatnot, the commission rate drops as your sales over each four-week period grow. Payment processing in the U.S. is a separate 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction. (Whatnot seller fees)

eBay Live has its own fee table too. For most categories, eBay lists a 6% commission, capped at $100 per item, plus 2.9% payment processing and a per-order fee. (eBay Live fees)

What the fee table doesn't tell you

The lowest fee isn't always the best place to sell. What you actually keep also depends on things a fee page can't show.

A simple way to choose

For each item, ask two questions. Where do items like this actually sell, based on sold listings? Then what will I keep there after fees and shipping?

Run the numbers for your two best options and pick the one that leaves the most money for the time it takes. Many sellers list the same item on more than one platform. If you do, remove it everywhere else as soon as it sells.

The short version

The fees here come from each marketplace's help pages as of November 2026. Platforms change fees often, so check the current page before you list.