MyHustle · Blog · News

Get the weekly digest

New posts and market headlines every Friday. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

Set your buy price before you pay: work back from sold prices

5 min read

You're standing in a thrift store holding a jacket with a $25 tag. It looks like a winner, but you don't know yet if it is one. Whether it makes money was mostly decided before you ever list it, at the moment you decide what to pay.

This post walks through one way to set your buy price on the spot. You work backward from what the item really sells for, subtract every cost that comes out of the sale, and stop at a number you won't go over.

Start with what it sold for, not what it's listed for

Asking prices tell you what other sellers hope to get. Sold prices tell you what buyers actually paid. Those two numbers can be far apart, especially on items that sit for months.

Before you buy, pull up recent sold listings for the same item on your phone. Look for the same brand, model, size, and condition. Then pick a price near the middle of what sold, not the best sale you can find.

Subtract what the marketplace keeps

Every platform takes a cut, and the cut is often larger than people expect because it applies to more than the item price. On eBay, the final value fee for most categories is 13.6% of the total amount of the sale, plus $0.40 per order over $10. That total includes the shipping the buyer pays and the sales tax. (eBay selling fees)

Here's a jacket that sells for $60. The buyer pays $10 shipping and, in this example, $4.90 in sales tax.

Total amount of the sale: $60 + $10 + $4.90 = $74.90

eBay fee: 13.6% × $74.90 = $10.19, plus $0.40 = $10.59

The sales tax passes through to the state, but eBay still charges its percentage on it. That's why you should run fees on the full total, not just the $60.

Subtract shipping and supplies

If the buyer pays $10 for shipping, the label may cost you about that. Your actual label cost depends on weight, size, and distance. A poly mailer, tape, and a printed label add a little more.

Keep going with the jacket. Say the label costs $10 and supplies cost $1.

What you keep before the purchase price: $60 + $10 − $10.59 − $10 − $1 = $48.41

That $48.41 is all the money there is. Whatever you pay for the jacket and whatever profit you want both have to come out of it.

Decide your profit first, then your buy price

Most resellers set a minimum dollar profit per item, not just a percentage. A small item with a big percentage can still pay you very little for the time it takes to photograph, list, pack, and ship.

If you want at least $20 profit on the jacket, the math gives you a ceiling:

Maximum buy price: $48.41 − $20 = $28.41

So the $25 tag works, with a little room to spare. If the tag said $35, you'd leave it on the rack, however good it looked.

Build a quick version you can do in the aisle

You won't always have time for the full math in a store. Once you've done it on a few items, you can build a rough shortcut for your usual categories.

Then check sold prices, take off fees, shipping, and your floor, and compare what's left to the tag.

Watch for the costs that don't show up on the tag

Some costs only show up later. Leave room for them, especially on items you've never sold before.

If you're unsure about an item, lower your maximum buy price instead of guessing high. Walking away from a maybe costs you nothing.

Write down what you paid, every time

Your buy price matters again when the item sells and again at tax time. Keep the receipt, or snap a photo of the tag and write the price on it. Later you can compare what you expected to make with what you actually made.

After a month of doing this, patterns show up. You'll see which stores, categories, and price points pay you, and which ones only feel like they do.

The short version

Fee rates change, and they differ by category and platform. Check the current fee page for the marketplace you plan to sell on before you lean on these numbers.